Police have arrested a man who allegedly tried to sell two 7-foot cow costumes designed for fast-food chain Chick-fil-A online, the Associated Press reports.

Robert Michael Trytten, 43, allegedly posted the black-and-white getups on Craigslist on Oct. 30, asking for $350 a piece, according to Redlands, Calif. police. An undercover officer met up with the seller to buy the costumes “for Halloween,” and arrested him. Trytten is now being held on a $275,000 bail for “suspicion of possession of the stolen property.”

The costumes, which were actually worth $2,800 a piece, were returned to the restaurant. No word on whether any “Eat More Chickin” signs were returned with the costumes as well.

MORE: British Police Catch Burglars with Fake Houses

MORE: Burglary Getaway Gone Miserably Bad

ncG1vNJzZmimlazAp7HEnWWtoZ2ae6S7zGhpaWljZH5ye49vZqGnnK56pLvWZqeopJmYsm6vwK2aoWWdlrtuv8Slo6Kml2LAtbvLnqVmb12bvLDAjJyfopubYrOquIyaZJynp2KwsL%2FTrqSeq18%3D